Trade-In vs Private Sale
Compare your options to see which puts more money in your pocket.
Your Current Car
What the dealer offered
Check KBB or Autotrader
Ads, detailing, minor repairs
New Car & Location
6.25% sales tax · Trade-in credit available
Recommended
Private Sale+$1,363
Trade-In
Private Sale
Comparing Your Options
Trade-In
Pros
- +Done in a single dealership visit
- +Tax savings in most states
- +No strangers, no hassle
- +Dealer handles paperwork
Cons
- -10-20% less than private sale
- -Less room to negotiate
Private Sale
Pros
- +10-20% more money
- +Full control over price
- +Can wait for the right buyer
Cons
- -Takes 2-6 weeks
- -Advertising costs ($50-200)
- -Deal with no-shows and lowballers
- -Handle paperwork yourself
- -No tax savings on new car
Trade-In Tax Savings
In most states, you only pay sales tax on the difference between your new car and trade-in value.
Example:
- New car: $40,000
- Trade-in: $15,000
- Taxable amount: $25,000
- At 7% tax: $1,050 saved
Some states (CA, HI, KY, MD, WA) don't offer this credit.
Common Questions
Is it better to trade in or sell privately?
It depends on what you value more. Trade-in is faster and easier. Private sale gets you more money but takes 2-4 weeks. Use the calculator above to compare your specific situation.
How much more can I get selling privately?
Typically 10-20% more than trade-in value. A $15,000 trade-in might sell for $16,500-$18,000 privately. Trade-in tax savings narrow this gap in most states.
How long does private sale take?
Typically 2-6 weeks. Popular models in good condition sell faster. Budget time for photos, listings, responding to inquiries, and showing the car.
Shopping for your next car?
See what others paid with verified deal data.
Browse Deals