Is This a Good Lease Deal? Free Lease Deal Checker
Quick answer
A lease is a good deal when three things line up: the selling price is discounted off MSRP about as much as other buyers get, before rebates; the money factor matches the manufacturer's advertised rate with no dealer markup; and the payment is near 1% of MSRP per month with nothing down beyond the first payment and fees.
By the CarWhere Research Team · Updated November 18, 2026 · Free verdict, no login
Have the dealer's quote? Upload it and we'll fill in the form.
Photo, screenshot, or PDF of the lease worksheet (max 4MB). Or skip this and type the numbers.
How the checker works
- Selling price vs the CarWhere Index. We take your discount off MSRP (selling price before rebates) and compare it with the CarWhere Index target for that model and year — the discount the better verified buyers got — applied to your quote's own MSRP.
- Money factor from the payment. Using your cap cost, residual, and term, we back out the money factor your payment implies. If the quote also states a money factor, we check the two agree.
- Money factor vs the advertised offer. When the manufacturer has a current advertised lease offer for the model, we compare against the money factor that offer implies and estimate the markup.
- 1% rule and effective cost. We divide the payment by MSRP, then spread due at signing across the term for the effective monthly cost. Cash down is shown as a $0-down equivalent so quotes compare fairly.
- A plain verdict. Good, fair, or overpaying, with the one or two changes worth the most money.
Worked example: spotting a money-factor markup
Take a $45,000 car sold for $42,300 (6% off), with a 58% residual over 36 months. At an advertised money factor of 0.00125 (3.0% APR), the pre-tax payment is $535.50: $450.00 of depreciation plus $85.50 of rent charge. If the quote instead shows $576.54, the payment implies a money factor of 0.00185 (4.44% APR). That gap costs $1,477 over the lease, and nothing about the car changed.
Lease deal questions
How do I know if a lease deal is good?
Check three things. First, the selling price: how far below MSRP it is before rebates, compared with what other buyers paid for the same model. Second, the money factor: whether it matches the manufacturer’s advertised rate or carries a dealer markup. Third, the payment: a monthly payment near 1% of MSRP, with little due at signing, is a strong lease.
What is the 1% rule for car leases?
The 1% rule says a strong lease costs about 1% of the car’s MSRP per month — $450 on a $45,000 car — with nothing but the first payment and fees due at signing. Up to about 1.5% is a fair lease for many models. It is a rule of thumb: high-residual cars beat it easily, and cars that lose value fast rarely reach it.
What is a good money factor on a lease?
A good money factor is the one the manufacturer’s lender advertises for your model and term, with no dealer markup. Multiply by 2,400 to get an approximate APR: 0.00125 is about 3.0%. Dealers are often allowed to mark the rate up, so compare the money factor in your quote with the advertised one, not with a general number.
How can I tell if the dealer marked up the money factor?
Work the money factor out from the payment: subtract the monthly depreciation, (cap cost − residual) ÷ term, from the pre-tax payment, then divide by (cap cost + residual). If the result is above the money factor implied by this month’s advertised offer, the difference is likely markup. This checker does that math for you and estimates what it costs over the lease.
Should I put money down on a lease?
Generally no. A down payment (cap cost reduction) only pre-pays part of the lease, and if the car is totaled or stolen early, insurance and GAP coverage pay the leasing company — the down payment is usually gone. Pay the first month and fees at signing, and compare quotes on a $0-down basis. This checker shows that $0-down equivalent payment.
Where does the price benchmark come from?
From the CarWhere Index: discounts off MSRP, before rebates, on verified buyer deals for the same make, model, and model year. We apply the Index target percentage to your quote’s MSRP and show how many deals it is based on. When there are too few deals, we say so instead of guessing.
Is the advertised-offer money factor the lender’s buy rate?
No. It is the money factor implied by the manufacturer’s current advertised lease offer for that model, which usually assumes top-tier credit and a specific trim, term, and mileage. Your buy rate can differ, so treat the markup figure as an estimate and ask the dealer to show the base rate in writing.
Do you keep my quote?
Only if you tick the box to add it to CarWhere’s lease data. Then we store the lease numbers as an unpublished deal for review. Any uploaded image stays in private storage, and only a redacted copy with names and contact details removed can ever be shown. Without the box ticked, nothing is saved from the check.