Data updated February 2026 · 2 verified transactions
Butler Toyota Jacksonville
Jacksonville, Florida · 2 verified deals · 0 lease, 2 cash/finance
1290 Cassat Ave, Jacksonville, FL 32205, USA
Transparency Score: 59/100
Score based on verified buyer data. Pricing vs market (40pts), fee transparency (30pts), data depth (30pts).
Is Butler Toyota Jacksonville a Good Dealer?
Butler Toyota Jacksonville earns a Grade C (59/100) based on 2 verified buyer transactions. Pricing is average for the Jacksonville market with 1.4% off MSRP and a $899 documentation fee. Consider comparing with other Jacksonville dealers before committing.
2
1.4%
below MSRP
$899
Based on 2 deals
1/2
deals with add-ons
CarWhere Pro
See target prices for every vehicle Butler Toyota Jacksonville sells. Know exactly what to pay before you walk in.
Get CarWhere ProWhat Fees Does Butler Toyota Jacksonville Charge?
Doc Fee Comparison
Documentation Fee
Based on 2 verified deal sheets
Dealer Add-ons & Accessories
| Item | Avg Amount | Seen In |
|---|---|---|
| Other Fees | $631 | 1/2 deals |
Pricing by Vehicle at Butler Toyota Jacksonville
Toyota Grand Highlander
2 deals · 1.4% off MSRP · avg $55,925
Toyota Grand Highlander
2 deals · 1.4% off MSRP · avg $55,925
2
Verified Deals
1.4%
Off MSRP
$55,925
Avg Price
Recent Deals at Butler Toyota Jacksonville
2026 Toyota Grand Highlander Limited FWD
MSRP $55,038
$53,538
2.7% off
2026 Toyota Grand Highlander Limited
MSRP $58,312
$58,312
0.0% off
Prices from verified buyer-submitted deal sheets. Individual results may vary.
Verified Transactions at Butler Toyota Jacksonville
| Year | Vehicle | Price | Discount |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | Toyota Grand Highlander | $53,538 | 2.7% |
| 2026 | Toyota Grand Highlander | $58,312 | 0.0% |
Prices from verified buyer-submitted deal sheets. VINs partially masked for privacy.
How Butler Toyota Jacksonville Compares
| Dealer | Grade | Avg Off MSRP | Doc Fee | Deals |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Butler Toyota Jacksonville(this dealer) | C(59) | 1.4% | $899 | 2 |
| Hanania | B(79) | 7.3% | $994 | 3 |
| Coggin Toyota at the Avenues | B(65) | 7.5% | — | 2 |
| Arlington Toyota | B(75) | 11.0% | $894 | 1 |
Based on verified buyer transactions. Scores reflect pricing, fee transparency, and data depth.
What to Know Before Visiting Butler Toyota Jacksonville
Butler Toyota Jacksonville in Jacksonville, Florida earns a Grade C (59/100) transparency score based on 2 verified buyer transactions. Buyers see modest discounts of 1.4% off MSRP. You may want to compare with other nearby dealers. Prices range from $53,538 to $58,312.
Their doc fee is $899 (Florida has no doc fee cap).
50% of verified deals included dealer add-ons. Watch for: Other Fees. These are negotiable — ask to have them removed.
Brands sold: Toyota.
All data sourced from verified buyer-submitted deal sheets. Not opinions — real transaction data.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Butler Toyota Jacksonville a good dealership?
Based on 2 verified buyer transactions, Butler Toyota Jacksonville in Jacksonville, FL earns a Grade C (59/100) transparency score. They sell vehicles at an average of 1.4% below MSRP. Their documentation fee is $899. 1 out of 2 deals included dealer add-ons. This data is based on real buyer-submitted deal sheets, not opinions.
Is Butler Toyota Jacksonville overpriced?
Butler Toyota Jacksonville sells vehicles at an average of 1.4% below MSRP. This is a modest discount. You may find better pricing at other dealers — check the CarWhere Index to compare. All data from 2 verified buyer deal sheets.
What fees does Butler Toyota Jacksonville charge?
Butler Toyota Jacksonville charges a documentation fee of $899. All fee data is sourced from verified buyer deal sheets.
What hidden fees does Butler Toyota Jacksonville charge?
Based on 2 verified deals, Butler Toyota Jacksonville commonly includes these add-ons: Other Fees (avg $631). These appeared in 1 out of 2 deals and are usually negotiable — ask to have them removed.
Does Butler Toyota Jacksonville negotiate on price?
Based on verified buyer transactions, buyers at Butler Toyota Jacksonville are getting an average of 1.4% off MSRP. This suggests the dealer is open to negotiation. For the 75th-percentile target discount for your specific vehicle — the level 25% of verified buyers got or beat — sign up for CarWhere PRO at $12.99/month.
Does Butler Toyota Jacksonville add dealer add-ons or pro packs?
Yes. In 1 out of 2 verified deals at Butler Toyota Jacksonville, dealer add-ons were included. Common add-ons: Other Fees (avg $631). These are almost always negotiable — ask to have them removed or discounted.
What should I pay at Butler Toyota Jacksonville for a Toyota Grand Highlander?
Based on 2 verified deals, buyers at Butler Toyota Jacksonville paid an average of $55,925 for a Toyota Grand Highlander, which is 1.4% below MSRP. For the exact 75th-percentile target price by trim — better than 75% of verified buyers — sign up for CarWhere PRO at $12.99/month.
What vehicles does Butler Toyota Jacksonville sell?
Based on verified buyer data, Butler Toyota Jacksonville has deals for: Toyota Grand Highlander (2 deals, avg 1.4% off).
See What Toyota Buyers Paid
Verified deals with real transaction prices and discounts
Have a deal from Butler Toyota Jacksonville?
Only 2 deals so far — your data makes a big difference
Own or manage this dealership?
Claim this page to update your info, respond to data, and connect with buyers