The 1% Rule (and 1.5% Rule) for Car Leases, Explained

By Sam Reynolds, Lead Researcher, CarWhere · Updated November 18, 2026

The short answer

The 1% rule says a lease is a strong deal when the monthly cost is about 1% of the car’s MSRP (including destination) or less — $400/mo on a $40,000 car. The 1.5% rule is the ceiling: above 1.5% of MSRP per month, the lease is usually expensive. Always fold due-at-signing money into the monthly number first.

How to calculate the 1% rule

Divide the lease’s effective monthly cost by the total MSRP (the window-sticker price including destination, before any discount). The rule uses MSRP — not the negotiated price — because the residual value, and therefore most of what you pay, is set off MSRP.

Formula

  • effective monthly = (due at signing + payment × (term − 1)) ÷ term
  • 1% rule ratio = effective monthly ÷ total MSRP × 100

The “term − 1” is there because advertised due-at-signing amounts already include the first payment. If your quote’s due-at-signing doesn’t include the first month, use payment × term instead.

What counts as good: the tier table

Effective monthly ÷ MSRPWhat it usually meansOn a $40,000 MSRP
1.00% or lessExceptional — usually heavy manufacturer support (lease cash, subvented money factor, high residual)≤ $400/mo
1.00%–1.25%Great to good$400–$500/mo
1.25%–1.50%Fair — the 1.5% rule’s acceptable band$500–$600/mo
Above 1.50%Expensive — check the money factor, residual and price> $600/mo

These bands are a widely used rule of thumb, not a lender standard. They are most useful for comparing two offers on similar cars, not as a pass/fail test.

See where this month’s advertised manufacturer leases actually land in the live table below.

This month: how advertised leases score (November 2026)

379 current advertised manufacturer lease programs on file state an MSRP. Their effective monthly cost (due at signing spread over the term) as a share of MSRP: median 1.30%.

BandProgramsShare
1.00% or less123%
1.00%–1.25%14538%
1.25%–1.50%16844%
Above 1.50%5414%

Lowest ratios on file:

  • 2026 Jeep Wrangler 4-door Sport S: $329/mo, 42 mo, $3,749 due at signing on $47,830 MSRP → 0.86% (through November 30, 2026)
  • 2026 RAM Ram 1500 Pickup Laramie: $409/mo, 42 mo, $5,439 due at signing on $60,740 MSRP → 0.87% (through November 30, 2026)
  • 2026 Hyundai Ioniq 9 SE: $449/mo, 36 mo, $4,999 due at signing on $64,415 MSRP → 0.89% (through November 30, 2026)
  • 2026 Toyota Tacoma SR5: $309/mo, 39 mo, $3,999 due at signing on $43,264 MSRP → 0.93% (through November 30, 2026)
  • 2026 GMC Sierra 1500 Elevation: $349/mo, 24 mo, $5,649 due at signing on $61,290 MSRP → 0.93% (through November 30, 2026)

Advertised manufacturer programs (California region where offered, else New York, else national), before taxes and dealer fees; regional programs differ. See all current offers on best lease deals.

Normalize for due at signing first

A big due-at-signing payment makes the monthly look small. Spread it across the term before you apply any rule. Here are two offers on the same $40,000 car:

Worked example — two 36-month offers, $40,000 MSRP

  • Offer A: $399/mo, $3,999 due at signing
  • effective = ($3,999 + $399 × 35) ÷ 36 = $499/mo → 1.25% of MSRP
  • Offer B: $459/mo, $459 due at signing (first month only)
  • effective = ($459 + $459 × 35) ÷ 36 = $459/mo → 1.15% of MSRP
  • Headline ratio for A: $399 ÷ $40,000 = 1.00% — looks like a “1% deal”, isn’t.

Offer B costs $1,440 less over the lease even though its payment is $60 higher. CarWhere’s position: don’t put money down on a lease — a down payment just prepays depreciation, and it is gone if the car is totaled or stolen. See the $0-down guide and gap insurance on a lease.

The 1.5% rule

The 1.5% rule is the same calculation with a higher bar: if the effective monthly cost is more than 1.5% of MSRP, the lease is likely overpriced, and you would usually do better negotiating harder, choosing a model with manufacturer lease support, or buying. On a $40,000 car that ceiling is $600/mo all-in; on a $60,000 car, $900/mo.

Most shoppers use the two together: 1% is the target, 1.5% is the walk-away line.

When the rule breaks

  • Taxes and fees. Monthly sales tax varies by state (some states tax the whole lease up front), so compare pre-tax numbers or use the same tax treatment on both sides.
  • Term and mileage. A 24-month or 10,000-mile lease will look worse than a 39-month, 7,500-mile one on the ratio even when it is the better deal for you.
  • Money factor markup. Two cars at 1.2% can hide very different rent charges. Ask for the money factor and compare it with the lender’s base rate — see money factor explained.
  • Brand and segment. Luxury cars with strong residuals and lease support hit 1% more often; trucks and many EVs rarely do. EVs also lost the federal lease credit for vehicles acquired after September 30, 2025, which raised many EV lease prices.
  • Very cheap cars. Fixed fees (acquisition fee, registration) are a bigger share of a $25,000 car, so 1% is harder to reach there.

Frequently asked questions

What is the 1% rule on lease deals?

A lease passes the 1% rule when its effective monthly cost — due at signing spread over the term plus the payment — is 1% of the car’s total MSRP or less. On a $45,000 car that is $450/mo all-in, before tax.

What is the 1.5% rule for a car lease?

The 1.5% rule sets the ceiling: an effective monthly cost above 1.5% of MSRP usually means the lease is overpriced. Between 1% and 1.5% is the normal range for a fair-to-good lease.

Should the 1% rule include taxes?

Use the same treatment on every offer you compare. Pre-tax is simplest because tax rules differ by state; just don’t compare a tax-included quote with a pre-tax advertisement.

Does the 1% rule use MSRP or the sale price?

MSRP including destination. The residual is calculated from MSRP, so the ratio measures how well the whole lease is structured. A lower negotiated price is how you get there.

Is a lease below 1% always a good deal?

Usually, but check the term, the mileage allowance and what is due at signing. A low ratio built on a large down payment, or on 7,500 miles a year when you drive 15,000, isn’t a good deal for you.

Related tools and guides

Sources

  1. Vehicle Leasing consumer guide — Comparing Lease Offers (archival) — Federal Reserve Board (checked 2026-11-18)
  2. 12 CFR 1013.4 — Content of lease disclosures — Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (checked 2026-11-18)
  3. Advertised manufacturer lease programs on file (stored daily; CA → NY → national region rule) — CarWhere