No Markup Car Dealers in New York
Dealerships selling at or below MSRP, verified by 87 real buyer transactions
What this means
Every dealer below has an average selling price at or below MSRP based on verified buyer-submitted deal sheets. No dealer markup, no market adjustment on average. Sorted by largest discount first.
New York No-Markup Dealers
| Dealer | City | Avg Off MSRP | Deals | Brands |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Riverhead Bay Motors | Riverhead | 22.7% off | 1 | Volkswagen |
| Jack Mcnerney Chevrolet | Tully | 12.0% off | 1 | Chevrolet |
| Bob Johnson Chevrolet | Rochester | 9.0% off | 2 | Chevrolet |
| Cooley Motors | Rensselaer | 9.0% off | 1 | Mazda |
| Mercedes-Benz of Rockville Centre | Rockville Centre | 9.0% off | 1 | Mercedes-Benz |
| Silver Star Motors | Long Island City | 8.4% off | 1 | Mercedes-Benz |
| Hoselton Chevrolet | East Rochester | 7.8% off | 1 | Chevrolet |
| Honda of Staten Island | Staten Island | 7.5% off | 7 | Honda |
| BMW of South Albany | Glenmont | 7.3% off | 3 | BMW |
| Mangino Buick GMC | Ballston Spa | 7.3% off | 1 | GMC |
| Mercedes-Benz of New Rochelle | New Rochelle | 7.0% off | 2 | Mercedes-Benz |
| Keeler Motor Car | Latham | 6.9% off | 2 | BMW |
| Northtown | Buffalo | 6.8% off | 4 | Mazda, Volkswagen |
| New Rochelle Toyota | New Rochelle | 6.8% off | 1 | Toyota |
| East Hills Sayville Volkswagen | Sayville | 6.5% off | 1 | Volkswagen |
| Williams Honda | Elmira | 6.2% off | 1 | Honda |
| Kinderhook Toyota | Hudson | 5.8% off | 3 | Toyota |
| Rensselaer Honda | Troy | 5.8% off | 2 | Honda |
| Audi Hawthorne | Hawthorne | 5.8% off | 2 | Audi |
| Bay Ridge Honda | Brooklyn | 5.8% off | 1 | Honda |
| Tasca Ford Mazda Subaru Yonkers | Yonkers | 5.6% off | 1 | Mazda |
| Romeo Toyota | Glens Falls | 5.6% off | 1 | Toyota |
| Gault Toyota | Endicott | 5.2% off | 3 | Toyota |
| Mazda White Plains | Elmsford | 5.2% off | 1 | Mazda |
| Volkswagen of Orchard Park | Orchard Park | 4.9% off | 2 | Volkswagen |
| Burdick BMW | Cicero | 4.8% off | 3 | BMW |
| Basil Volkswagen of Lockport | Lockport | 4.7% off | 1 | Volkswagen |
| Ellis Automotive, | Malone | 4.3% off | 1 | Chevrolet |
| Davis Moore | Schenectady | 4.2% off | 2 | Chevrolet |
| Riverhead Mazda | Riverhead | 4.0% off | 1 | Mazda |
| Jessica Chevrolet | Honeoye Falls | 3.9% off | 4 | Chevrolet |
| Maguire Imports | Ithaca | 3.9% off | 2 | Volvo |
| Williams Toyota of Elmira | Horseheads | 3.9% off | 1 | Toyota |
| Hudson Valley Volkswagen | Wappingers Falls | 3.6% off | 5 | Volkswagen |
| Tradition Buick GMC | Newark | 3.4% off | 1 | Chevrolet |
| Lia Cars | Schenectady | 3.4% off | 1 | Honda |
| Depaula Mazda | Albany | 3.1% off | 1 | Mazda |
| Nemer Volkswagen of Colonie | Schenectady | 2.3% off | 1 | Volkswagen |
| Mercedes-Benz of Rochester | Rochester | 2.0% off | 1 | Mercedes-Benz |
| Smith Haven Mazda | St James | 1.7% off | 1 | Mazda |
| West Herr Toyota of Williamsville | Williamsville | 1.5% off | 2 | Toyota |
| Atlantic Honda | Bay Shore | 1.4% off | 2 | Honda |
| Tasca Volkswagen White Plains | White Plains | 1.4% off | 1 | Volkswagen |
| Burdick Mazda | Cicero | 1.3% off | 1 | Mazda |
| Riverhead Ford | Riverhead | 1.3% off | 1 | Ford |
| BMW of Bay Shore | Bay Shore | 1.0% off | 1 | BMW |
| Dv Burdick Ford | Cicero | 0.9% off | 1 | Ford |
| Darcars BMW of Mt. Kisco | Mount Kisco | 0.0% off | 2 | BMW |
| Mike Basil Toyota | Lockport | 0.0% off | 1 | Toyota |
| Riverhead Toyota | Riverhead | 0.0% off | 1 | Toyota |
| Lexus of Freeport | Freeport | 0.0% off | 1 | Lexus |
| Romeo KIA | Lake Katrine | 0.0% off | 1 | Kia |
Riverhead Bay Motors
Riverhead, NY
1 verified deals22.7% off MSRP
Volkswagen
Jack Mcnerney Chevrolet
Tully, NY
1 verified deals12.0% off MSRP
Chevrolet
Bob Johnson Chevrolet
Rochester, NY
2 verified deals9.0% off MSRP
Chevrolet
Cooley Motors
Rensselaer, NY
1 verified deals9.0% off MSRP
Mazda
Mercedes-Benz of Rockville Centre
Rockville Centre, NY
1 verified deals9.0% off MSRP
Mercedes-Benz
Silver Star Motors
Long Island City, NY
1 verified deals8.4% off MSRP
Mercedes-Benz
Hoselton Chevrolet
East Rochester, NY
1 verified deals7.8% off MSRP
Chevrolet
Honda of Staten Island
Staten Island, NY
7 verified deals7.5% off MSRP
Honda
BMW of South Albany
Glenmont, NY
3 verified deals7.3% off MSRP
BMW
Mangino Buick GMC
Ballston Spa, NY
1 verified deals7.3% off MSRP
GMC
Mercedes-Benz of New Rochelle
New Rochelle, NY
2 verified deals7.0% off MSRP
Mercedes-Benz
Keeler Motor Car
Latham, NY
2 verified deals6.9% off MSRP
BMW
Northtown
Buffalo, NY
4 verified deals6.8% off MSRP
MazdaVolkswagen
New Rochelle Toyota
New Rochelle, NY
1 verified deals6.8% off MSRP
Toyota
East Hills Sayville Volkswagen
Sayville, NY
1 verified deals6.5% off MSRP
Volkswagen
Williams Honda
Elmira, NY
1 verified deals6.2% off MSRP
Honda
Kinderhook Toyota
Hudson, NY
3 verified deals5.8% off MSRP
Toyota
Rensselaer Honda
Troy, NY
2 verified deals5.8% off MSRP
Honda
Audi Hawthorne
Hawthorne, NY
2 verified deals5.8% off MSRP
Audi
Bay Ridge Honda
Brooklyn, NY
1 verified deals5.8% off MSRP
Honda
Tasca Ford Mazda Subaru Yonkers
Yonkers, NY
1 verified deals5.6% off MSRP
Mazda
Romeo Toyota
Glens Falls, NY
1 verified deals5.6% off MSRP
Toyota
Gault Toyota
Endicott, NY
3 verified deals5.2% off MSRP
Toyota
Mazda White Plains
Elmsford, NY
1 verified deals5.2% off MSRP
Mazda
Volkswagen of Orchard Park
Orchard Park, NY
2 verified deals4.9% off MSRP
Volkswagen
Burdick BMW
Cicero, NY
3 verified deals4.8% off MSRP
BMW
Basil Volkswagen of Lockport
Lockport, NY
1 verified deals4.7% off MSRP
Volkswagen
Ellis Automotive,
Malone, NY
1 verified deals4.3% off MSRP
Chevrolet
Davis Moore
Schenectady, NY
2 verified deals4.2% off MSRP
Chevrolet
Riverhead Mazda
Riverhead, NY
1 verified deals4.0% off MSRP
Mazda
Jessica Chevrolet
Honeoye Falls, NY
4 verified deals3.9% off MSRP
Chevrolet
Maguire Imports
Ithaca, NY
2 verified deals3.9% off MSRP
Volvo
Williams Toyota of Elmira
Horseheads, NY
1 verified deals3.9% off MSRP
Toyota
Hudson Valley Volkswagen
Wappingers Falls, NY
5 verified deals3.6% off MSRP
Volkswagen
Tradition Buick GMC
Newark, NY
1 verified deals3.4% off MSRP
Chevrolet
Lia Cars
Schenectady, NY
1 verified deals3.4% off MSRP
Honda
Depaula Mazda
Albany, NY
1 verified deals3.1% off MSRP
Mazda
Nemer Volkswagen of Colonie
Schenectady, NY
1 verified deals2.3% off MSRP
Volkswagen
Mercedes-Benz of Rochester
Rochester, NY
1 verified deals2.0% off MSRP
Mercedes-Benz
Smith Haven Mazda
St James, NY
1 verified deals1.7% off MSRP
Mazda
West Herr Toyota of Williamsville
Williamsville, NY
2 verified deals1.5% off MSRP
Toyota
Atlantic Honda
Bay Shore, NY
2 verified deals1.4% off MSRP
Honda
Tasca Volkswagen White Plains
White Plains, NY
1 verified deals1.4% off MSRP
Volkswagen
Burdick Mazda
Cicero, NY
1 verified deals1.3% off MSRP
Mazda
Riverhead Ford
Riverhead, NY
1 verified deals1.3% off MSRP
Ford
BMW of Bay Shore
Bay Shore, NY
1 verified deals1.0% off MSRP
BMW
Dv Burdick Ford
Cicero, NY
1 verified deals0.9% off MSRP
Ford
Darcars BMW of Mt. Kisco
Mount Kisco, NY
2 verified deals0.0% off MSRP
BMW
Mike Basil Toyota
Lockport, NY
1 verified deals0.0% off MSRP
Toyota
Riverhead Toyota
Riverhead, NY
1 verified deals0.0% off MSRP
Toyota
Lexus of Freeport
Freeport, NY
1 verified deals0.0% off MSRP
Lexus
Romeo KIA
Lake Katrine, NY
1 verified deals0.0% off MSRP
Kia
Frequently Asked Questions
Which New York dealers sell at or below MSRP?
Based on verified buyer transactions, 52 dealerships in New York have an average selling price at or below MSRP. Top dealers include Riverhead Bay Motors (22.7% off), Jack Mcnerney Chevrolet (12.0% off), Bob Johnson Chevrolet (9.0% off).
What does "no markup" mean?
"No markup" means the dealer sells at MSRP (sticker price) or below — no market adjustment, no Additional Dealer Markup (ADM). Based on verified buyer deal sheets, these dealers have an average selling price at or below the manufacturer's suggested retail price.
Are no-markup dealers really cheaper?
Yes. A "no markup" dealer sells at or below MSRP, while some dealers add $1,000-$15,000+ in market adjustments on popular models. However, watch for dealer add-ons (paint protection, pro packs, etc.) which can effectively add cost even without an explicit markup. Check individual dealer profiles on CarWhere for full fee transparency.